Can the Kingdom of Heaven be fought for?

Our history is chock full of some gut-wrenching atrocities that have been committed in the name of various gods. Does this bring us closer to the Kingdom of Heaven? Nirvana? WallyWorld?

I would say no. In fact, I would say that violence should never be used aggressively. Self Defense is one thing, but going out and killing others for no good reason? Or, even for a good reason?

If we assume that a stepping stone on the path to WallyWorld is a world where peace reigns, then we can look at every aggressive act as moving us further away from WallyWorld. When you are aggressively violent, and even when you are defensively violent, you do more then just hurt some one’s body, you damage the psyche of the community. Looking at 9/11, the people that did that were horrid people. They scarred the Americans collective psyche for generations to come. We are still dealing with the ramification of this. The Patriot Act, the War Hawks, the extreme split between the Right and Left.

A small percentage of us shouted for revenge! We wanted the people responsible dead. A larger percentage of us shouted for Justice! We wanted to see the perpetrators brought to justice. Another group of us shouted for, well, nothing. To hide and hope that it would not happen again.

My feelings at the time ranged from Revenge to Justice. But, the point is that there is an equal and opposite reaction for every action. That is what the Terrorists see, and count on. Look at the shooting today in Gaza. They count on the fact that the targets will become enraged, and topple the peace process.

With the notion that “to kill an infidel is not murder – it’s the path to heaven”, there was the prevalent concept that heaven can be won through putting non-believers through “hell”, which they are deemed to deserve. But how can anyone be rewarded karmically through acts of hateful violence? “God wills it!” is uttered as a war cry throughout the film, but it is obvious in many instances that it was the deluded men themselves, who willed what they did, while the gods themselves remain ominously silent. It forces the audience to question how much were they fighting for God and how much for themselves, to covet land and wealth. Grave ungodliness in the name of God?

Can the Elusive “Kingdom of Heaven” be Fought For? about the movie Kingdom of Heaven

If God is in fact a God of Love, then how can people even think that he would have us make war on each other, and maim, torture and kill each other in his name? I believe very strongly that acts of war, torture and what have you are in fact not divine in origin, rather are man made, and God is simply used as convenient rationalization. I believe that if God is still watching over us, if there is a God, he/she/it is disgusted.

More then that: Entrance into WallyWorld is predicated on a certain behavioral standard. It is rare to see such a standard which includes mass murder. In the Buddhist philosophy, each negative act garners you bad karma. Any bad karma that you have, must be worked off before you can reach the level of calm that enlightenment requires. So, the mass murderers probably will not attain WallyWorld any time soon.

The question of self defense has often bothered me. As a Buddhist, if I am attacked, am I simply to stand and die? If my Family is attacked, am I just to watch in horror? That is where I draw the line. I am a pacifist. I do not think that killing or violence is a good answer to any question. However, when force is brought to the table, I will respond in a fashion that will assure the safety of me and mine.

I have a very high level of respect for the Police Officers and Solders in this world. Most do an outstanding job of taking the community on as ‘family’ and protecting them all. The eventual answer to violence will be two pronged. First we have to assure that the misguided people who think that they can initiate violence to get what they want are stopped cold. We also need to be able to teach a lifestyle of tolerance, and peaceful response to stress.

This War on Terror will not be won with bullets and bombs – if you consider winning to be a more peaceful world. However, those bullets and bombs just might buy us the time to engage in the discussion and diplomacy that will win the war.

4 thoughts on “Can the Kingdom of Heaven be fought for?”

  1. I am pretty sure we agree, at least more than not on this.

    Certainly unless one is willing to advocate a ‘final solution’ violence alone will not solve this problem (and that solution would be worse than our current problems.)

    However, many use reasoning like that presented in your post (albeit without the caveat of violence being needed to buy us time) as a means of supporting the notion that violence itself is wrong, even in deffence or for the protection of others. That type of reasoning, in my belief, is as much, perhaps more, guilty of allowing atrocities as any religious beliefs.

    When good men feel that being good means not opposing evil, they are allowing evil to flourish.

  2. Thus "However, those bullets and bombs just might buy us the time to engage in the discussion and diplomacy that will win the war."

    I think that it’s not about not using violence, it’s about realising that will not implement the changes that we want. They are one of many tools that we have to use to quash terror – nothing more and nothing less.

  3. And in responst to your title, I’ll let God worry about the Kingdom of Heaven.

    I know damn well though that we sometimes have to fight for the Civilization of Earth.

  4. "First we have to assure that the misguided people who think that they can initiate violence to get what they want are stopped cold."

    I think that this is critical. Being peaceful and non-aggressive is all well and good, but when it crosses into excusing and failing to confront evil, it is no longer noble. When possible, stopping the bad guys without using violence is great, but the bad guys will use violence, and if the good guys won’t use violence to stop them, the bad guys will win.

Comments are closed.